Rental Property vs. REIT - Where Should You Invest Your Money?

The most significant advantage of REITs is that they allow regular investors to participate in commercial properties.

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Rental Property vs. REIT - Where Should You Invest Your Money?

Adding real estate to your investment portfolio can help you diversify, increase profits, and even hedge against inflation risk. When it comes to investing in real estate, though, you have a few options. Rental property and real estate investment trusts are two of the most common real estate investing options (REITs). But, what are the advantages and disadvantages of each of these investment vehicles for you and your portfolio? Which is the better investment: REITs or rental property? 

Also Read: Here’s How NRI Investors Can Make Most From Their Rental Earnings In India

Rental property vs. REIT

You must first grasp how each real estate asset class works before deciding which is best for your investment portfolio.

  • Property for rent

The concept of rental property is familiar to the majority of people. Residential property, such as a single- or multifamily home, condominium, or apartment building, can be purchased and rented out by investors. This property should, in theory, bring in more rent each month than the investor spends in mortgage, taxes, insurance, maintenance, and other costs. Any delta generates a monthly cash flow profit for the investor, which they can save or reinvest in the property. The hope is that the rental property would appreciate over time or after a renovation.

  • Real Estate Investment Trust (REIT)

A REIT (real estate investment trust) operates in a somewhat different way. You buy shares in a REIT, which is a trust that owns and manages real estate. You will have no say in the property held by a REIT, and you will have no involvement or responsibility in its management as an investor. Investors get dividends when the REIT’s assets appreciate and generate profit. If an investor needs to sell his REIT shares at any point, he can do so. 

If an investor has to sell his REIT shares at a later date, he can do so at the current market value. REITs come in three varieties: publicly traded, privately traded, and public non-traded. Each has its investment requirements and money accessibility, and each runs in a somewhat different way.

Read Also: Top Features Of A Profitable Rental Property – Do They Make Reliable Assets For Retirement?

Similarities between REITs and Rental Properties

Investing in rental property and REITs are comparable, if not identical, in many aspects. Here are some examples of how the two possibilities intersect.

  • Cash Flow 

Both REITs and rental properties might supply you with a source of cash flow if you’re seeking a cash-flowing investment. REITs must disperse at least 90% of their taxable revenue to investors in the form of dividends, according to the IRS. As a result, REITs are a dependable source of this type of passive income. A rental property might also supply you with regular income flow in the correct circumstances. However, market rental pricing, property taxes, vacancies, and even maintenance all play a role.

  • Capital Appreciation

Many investors consider rental property and REITs to be good long-term investments since they both have the potential for high growth and asset gain. If and when these assets improve in value, investors can expect increasing cash flow regularly. Any increase in value will be recognized by the investor when the assets are sold later. 

  • Volatility 

Another similarity between REITs and rental property is that both can be volatile and have value fluctuations over time. Investors would likely feel the effects of a REIT’s reduced profit margin – whether owing to rising expenses or market dynamics – through smaller dividend payouts. This reduced cash flow may influence your budget and other financial endeavors. If you need to liquidate your portfolio, REIT volatility can be a problem. When it comes time to sell your REIT, you will notice if the price has plummeted since you bought it.

Volatility, unscrupulous renters, and plummeting property values are just a few of the threats that rental property faces. Rental costs might change in tandem with the rest of the real estate market, resulting in lower rents and even longer vacancies. Increased property taxes or unforeseen costly repairs, which are the responsibility of the owner-investor, might also generate volatility.

  • Both offer diversification 

Real estate investing can help diversify your investment portfolio, better secure your assets, and lessen the impact of market downturns and inflation. Both rental property and REITs help to diversify your portfolio by incorporating real estate investments. The more diverse these investments are, the better diversified your portfolio will be: this could involve buying several REITs or several forms of investment property or investing in multiple places.

Also Read: A Beginner’s Guide To Investing In REITs

The Differences Between a REIT and a Rental Property

If you want to make an informed investment decision, you need to understand the differences between rental properties and REITs.

  • Direct ownership receives tax benefits.

Many IRS tax deductions are available to property owners who have an investment property. Mortgage interest, property taxes, repairs, management, and other expenses can all be written off. Investors in REITs do not get these kinds of tax savings.

Also Read: Wanna save tax on your rental investment? Here is everything you should know!

  • Flexibility and control

You don’t have much (or any) control over your REIT investment, whether you wish to choose the next batch of tenants or just paint colors. You should choose rental property if you want to be more hands-on with your investment.

  • Possibility of utilizing as collateral

You may be able to borrow against a portion of your rental property’s equity (or the value that you own) as needed if you own a rental property. This can be accomplished with the help of a home equity loan or a home equity line of credit.

  • Active vs. Passive investments

One key distinction to keep in mind is that rental property is an active investment, whereas REITs are a passive one. Even if you engage a management company to handle the majority of the day-to-day choices, rental property demands a hands-on approach and regular attention. REITs, on the other hand, allow investors to “set it and forget it” when it comes to investing. Except for receiving dividend payments and watching your asset(s) develop, there’s nothing else you have to do once you’ve purchased shares in your REIT.

  • Liquidity

If you ever need to sell your investments, REITs may be a better option than renting a home. You’ll almost always have to sell a rental property to get rid of it. Between preparing and listing the house, showing the property, and closing on a transaction, can take a lot of time, effort, and money. A rental property asset can take months to liquidate from start to completion. However, with REITs, it might be as simple as pressing a button on your brokerage’s app. If you possess publicly traded REITs, you can sell them in minutes (if not seconds) if a buyer is willing to buy them.

  • Costs and investments upfront

For investors, a rental property can be many things, but cheap on the front end isn’t usually one of them. To buy a rental property, investors must have enough money to cover the down payment, earnest money, and closing charges. If renovations are required, the investor must either pay cash or obtain a loan.

You may often get started investing in REITs with as little as a few dollars. While some REITs (especially those that are privately traded or non-traded) have hefty investment minimums, many others are available on ordinary brokerage platforms with no such limitations.

Read also: 7 Tips to keep rental income consistent year-round!

REITs vs. Rental- The safer option

As you can see, both property rental purchases and REITs have their own set of advantages and disadvantages. The safest option is determined by your particular investing preferences and what you genuinely desire from your investment. Investing in real estate, regardless of which path you take, is a terrific method to supplement your income and diversify your assets and financial portfolio.

Also Read: Indian Income Tax Rules Favour REIT Investors To Earn High Profits

It’s critical to consider the benefits and drawbacks outlined above and choose the choice that best fits your lifestyle, as well as the amount of time, effort, risk, and money you’re willing to devote. Housing will always be a requirement. As a result, it’s a far better investment alternative. While prices in the housing market may fluctuate, overall demand for housing remains consistent.

Do you like to take a step back and let things happen on their own? Then think about include REITs in your portfolio. Are you seeking a tax-advantaged investment that also gives you more control? Then a rental home is a good option. Purchasing rental property with REIT shares may be the ideal happy medium for some investors. After all, the more diversified your investment portfolio is today, the more protected you will be in the future markets. The best option depends on an investor’s objectives and investment style; in some circumstances, combining REITs and rental properties may be the best option.  Assetmonk is a WealthTech platform offering real estate investment opportunities in top cities like Bangalore, Hyderabad, and Chennai with an IRR of 14-21%. Visit our website to start investing with us!!

Rental Property vs. REIT FAQ'S

A rental property is a residence or commercial that is leased or rented to a renter for a defined length of time. There are holiday rentals and long-term rentals, such as those with a one-to-three-year contract.

The primary advantage of REITs is that they allow individual investors to profit from real estate without having to own, operate, or finance properties directly. They provide a low-cost method of real estate investment. REIT shares, like stocks, can be bought and sold on an exchange.

Related Articles

istockphoto 817688664 612x612 2

Tier-II Indian cities emerge as significant real estate development engines

According to a report, there has been an increase in the absorption and supply of quality residential homes across price ranges in Ahmedabad, Vadodara, Nashik, Gandhi Nagar, and Jaipur. According to a recent analysis produced by real estate data analytics and consultancy firm PropEquity, Ahmedabad, Vadodara, Nashik, Gandhi Nagar, and Jaipur are the top tier-II cities in terms of residential property market growth. According to the research, the surge has been fueled by rising urbanization, industrialization, and the expansion of the IT industry. According to the report, titled ‘Tier-II: Residential Overview,’ there has been a boom in the absorption and supply of quality residential properties in these locations across price groups. From FY18 to FY22, the report tracked the performance of the residential segment in various tier-II cities. Tier-2 cities’ real estate activity is rapidly catching up to that of tier-1 cities. Interestingly, Ahmedabad’s residential real estate market size of Rs 83,390 crore outstripped that of major tier-1 cities like…

Read more
istockphoto 1215474286 612x612 1

Stock Market Too Rocky For You? Here’s Why Fractional Ownership Is the best Alternative Investment Now

Most of us started 2022 with high hopes for what the new year would bring. But we had no idea what it had in store for us. Russia-Ukraine war. Inflation. A major surprise indeed, right? As obvious as it is, 2022 has so far been unkind to investors, with most major stock markets, including the S&P 500, suffering significant losses and entering bear markets. At the heart of all this volatility is the uneasiness of investors. So, where else can we invest with ease then? Fractional ownership of the commercial real estate. When we mention investing in stocks to friends and family, one of the first questions they ask is, “Aren’t stocks risky?” “I don’t want to risk losing my money,” or anything along those lines. Well, yes. The stock market may undoubtedly be a hazardous place to spend your money if you don’t grasp the dangers connected with investing in stocks and take necessary measures to reduce those risks.…

Read more
istockphoto 1393849012 612x612 1

Boost in demand for real estate in suburban areas of Hyderabad

Hyderabad’s suburbs have recently witnessed an increase in the rates of real estate properties. Places like the Jubilee Hills, Gachibowli, Nizampet, Kondapur, and Madhapur are also in the same situation. Also, areas like Gopanally, Manikoda, and Narsingi are facing increased demand due to the rise in prices of real estate. Hyderabad was uncertain about having much real estate activity at the time. People are becoming more interested in developing IT enterprises, tech parks, and commercial institutions, which has resulted in rising real estate prices in the suburbs. Knight Frank has observed an increase in demand for real estate in Hyderabad’s neighboring areas. The study featured a rise in real estate sales from Hyderabad’s four residential marketing districts, including Hyderabad, Medchal- Malkajgiri, Rangareddy, and Sangareddy. Further estimated reports of registration According to an analysis of home sale registrations, the Medchal-Malkajgiri district comes out on top with 44%, trailed by the Rangareddy district with 38%. In contrast, the Hyderabad district accounts for…

Read more
istockphoto 547451008 612x612 1

Real Estate: A money making alternative investment for you in 2022

Real estate is one of the hottest alternative investment options in recent times. The market value as well as the growth potential of the real estate industry is growing ever since urbanization began in India. It has attracted the wider attention of the crowd that is keen to invest in various forms of alternative investments. But, is real estate the one that’s perfect for money-making? To answer this and other queries about commercial real estate as an alternative investment, we’re glad to present you with this informative article. Stay tuned until the end! Why is commercial real estate becoming increasingly popular among investors? Commercial real estate is one of the few industries in this country that has survived massive economic blows at times. The recent pandemic couldn’t affect this industry on a large scale. The commercial real estate industry is very stable and promises one of the highest magnitudes of returns in the long term. Also, the demand for the…

Read more
istockphoto 155700839 612x612 1

Rental housing demand will increase in crucial micro markets

The real estate market has exploded in the post-pandemic era. The corporate market is increasing, increasing demand for commercial space and rental residences. According to industry statistics, in the second quarter of this year, Indian rental home searches climbed 84.4% year on year and 29.4% sequentially. Furthermore, total combined rental housing listings rose 3% quarter on quarter and 28.1% year on year throughout the 13 Indian cities covered. Do not miss The 18% GST on rent gets anticipated to harm the rental housing industry. But, what are the variables that will lead to the rental housing demand boom? Accessibility and cost-effectiveness: When it comes to renting a property, people primarily examine three factors: infrastructure, connection, and price. The property’s location, with ready infrastructure and decent connection, takes precedence over the size and price of the unit. Customers want a home in a prominent location that allows them to maintain a good work-life balance, with less commuting time, easier access to…

Read more
istockphoto 1393356971 612x612 1

REITs, New Age Instrument: Investing in Properties Without Actually Investing in One

Real estate investing always meant purchasing, owning, and managing an actual property. But, did you know that it can still be done without actually owning the property? Thanks to REITs, investors need only put their money into corporations that possess substantial portfolios of self-appreciating real estate assets in some of the world’s most desired locales. Welcome to the world of REITs where you can buy real estate without the inconvenience of owning the property altogether. Easy peasy lemon squeezy right? Real estate investment trusts are popular among investors who wish to buy real estate without the inconvenience of owning the property altogether. These investments, known as REITs, allow investors to deposit money into income-producing real estate. A REIT is best described as a simple way to own real estate without actually purchasing any property. Investors can acquire individual shares of a real estate investment trust, similar to stocks, which gives them little chunks of several properties. This protects them from…

Read more