Listen to the article
- When it comes to mutual fund investments, the decision to opt for Systematic Investment Plans known as Sip. SIP vs LumpSum investment can be a puzzling one. Even more so, if you’re a young investor or a middle class professional making your foray into mutual funds.
- On the one hand, you might have a surplus of money to invest, but you’re not really sure whether to inject it into a mutual fund all in one go or go for the periodic investment approach.
- Choosing between periodic SIPS vs going or a one-time LumpSum investment all depends on how familiar you are with different types of mutual funds, the particular fund you have in mind, and your financial goals and portfolio.
What is SIP?
- Picture Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) as consistent and periodic rainfall, nurturing your portfolio every month with the rain it brings. In SIPS, investors commit to regular contributions to the mutual funds at fixed intervals.
- This makes it easier on the wallet as compared to LumpSum investments. Instead of parting with all of your money saved for investing at once, you spread it out over a fixed period of time. This strategy gives a more disciplined approach, is ideal for beginner investors, and also acts as a shield against the unpredictability of the market.
- As per data from AMFI, the Association of Mutual Funds in India, the inflows in SIPs in the first 11 months of 2023 rose to 1.66 lakh crores, much higher than the total SIP investment in 2022. This suggests that investors are significantly favouring SIPs.
- The Securities & Exchange Board of India (SEBI) also recently lowered the minimum investment level for SIPs from 500 to 250, and even Rs 100 for what are now being called micro-SIPs, which is further fuelling investment.
LumpSum Investment in Mutual Funds
- Keeping our metaphor going, LumpSum investments are like a sudden downpour of rain, hitting your farm all at once and inundating it with a huge amount of yield in one go.
- LumpSum investments offer the allure of immediate potential returns, but it also exposes investors to the whims of market fluctuations without the protection of gradual investment.
- The minimum investment in LumpSum investment mutual funds varies, but is typically around Rs 5000. And as per AMFI, August-September 2023 saw equity MF schemes reach record LumpSum investments of Rs 35,270 crore, a sharp increase from Rs 5,550 crores in the months preceding.
SIP vs LumpSum Investment: Which is Better?
A number of factors go into deciding whether you should opt for systematic investment plans or LumpSum in mutual funds. Here are some:
- Market Timing
Due to their period nature, SIPs eliminate the pressure of trying to find the perfect market entry time, and they favour the concept of rupee-cost averaging. Meaning, investors buy more units when prices are low, and fewer when prices are high, effectively reducing the impact of market timing.
Investors opting for LumpSum thrive on being able to time the market correctly. Their entire investment is dependent upon strategically entering when prevailing market conditions are favourable and then deploying a huge investment in the particular fund.
- Risk Mitigation
The systematic and phased approach of SIPs serves as a risk mitigation strategy. By spreading investments over various market cycles, investors are shielded from the full brunt of market volatility.
With immediate exposure to market conditions, LumpSum investments are inherently riskier, lacking the protective cushion of rupee-cost averaging.
- Rate of Return
Capitalizing on the power of compounding, SIPs allow returns to accumulate over an extended period. The consistent and disciplined approach amplifies the benefits of compounding.
LumpSum investments offer the potential of higher immediate returns, and compounding is influenced by market conditions prevailing at the time of investment.
- Psychological Impact
SIPs instil a sense of financial discipline and peace of mind. The gradual nature of SIPs reduces the emotional stress associated with sudden market fluctuations.
On the flipside, LumpSum investments can be psychologically demanding, especially during market downturns as the full impact of the invested sum is immediately felt.
sip vs LumpSum Investment in Mutual Funds: Comparing Returns
| Criteria | Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) | LumpSum Investment |
| Investment Approach | Regular fixed contributions at predetermined intervals | One-time substantial investment |
| Market Timing | Eliminates the need for precise market timing; embraces rupee-cost averaging | Requires strategic market timing for optimal entry |
| Risk Management | Risk is mitigated through rupee-cost averaging, spreading investments over time | Prone to higher risk due to immediate exposure to market conditions |
| Returns and Compounding | Capitalizes on the power of compounding over an extended period | Potential for higher immediate returns, compounding influenced by market conditions at the time of investment |
| Psychological Impact | Provides financial discipline and peace of mind | Can be psychologically demanding, especially during market downturns |
| Minimum Investment Level | Relatively low; varies by mutual fund, typically ranging from Rs 250 to Rs 1000 | Higher, often requiring a LumpSum amount ranging from Rs 5,000 to even Rs 50,000 or more |
| Expected/Potential Rates of Return | Historically offers moderate to high returns over the long term | Potential for higher immediate returns, but overall returns influenced by market conditions |
Keep in mind, that different mutual funds have different expected/potential rates of return based on the particular assets you’re investing in and the type of investment strategy opted for.
For example, in 2023, 5 equity funds tripled their investors’ wealth in 5 years, as per data from ETMutualFunds, and gave a Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) of 28.8%, which is very high indeed.
What Type of Mutual Fund Investor Are You?
Young & Risk Taking Investors
Investors comfortable with risk and seeking high potential returns will find LumpSum investments in line with their investment goals. However, a diversified approach, with other investments such as commercial real estate can help in mitigating risk and develop a better, more rounded portfolio.
Conservative Investors
Investors looking for a disciplined, consistent approach will always find systematic investment in mutual funds more suitable. The steady accumulation of wealth aligns with a risk averse strategy.
Retirees & Stable Monthly Income Seekers
SIPs in mutual funds will be preferable for retirees or experienced individuals seeking a stable income stream. Alternatively, you can look to invest in other avenues such as commercial real estate, fractional ownership, or commercial subleasing, all of which can offer stable monthly income through rental income derived from leasing commercial real estate properties.
Bottom Line: Choosing the Right Path for You
A nuanced approach is crucial while deciding whether to opt for SIPs or LumpSum investment in mutual funds. The choice between the two hinges on an investor’s tolerance for risk, their financial goals, and the time duration of the investment. It is also important to diversify your portfolio and not put all your eggs in one basket.
In the current investment landscape, real estate, especially commercial real estate, shines through as a beacon. Assetmonk, an alternative realty investment platform offers a distinctive approach to invest in commercial real estate through alternative investment models, such as fractional ownership.
Assetmonk is always ready to guide investors on their journey towards building a well-rounded and prosperous portfolio.
Read More
