Fractional Ownership & REITs: Questions Answered By A Professional Real Estate Lawyer

Understanding the basics of REITs and Fractional Ownership, and knowing the differences and their suitability is important before taking the final decision of investing.

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Fractional Ownership & REITs: Questions Answered By A Professional Real Estate Lawyer

One thing is certain: commercial real estate dominates the Indian investment market. There are two new-age investment formats — fractional property and REITs (Real Estate Investment Trusts) — that are ushering in this new era in India’s financial world. Fractional Ownership and Real Estate Investment Trusts are the emerging ways of investing in the real estate sector. No doubt people are already curious about trying out newly tech-enabled   ways to optimize their real estate investments and particularly in the Commercial Property segment. However, many investors find REITs or Fractional Ownership investments a little overwhelming due to the sudden popularity they gained from a larger investor base. Understanding the basics of REITs and Fractional Ownership, and knowing the differences and their suitability is important before taking the final decision of investing. Hence, to add to your knowledge, we bring you a detailed comparison of both and outline which investment is suitable for your investing goals. 

What is Fractional Ownership in Real Estate?

Fractional Ownership in its literal terms means part ownership in any asset. Just like owning a percentage of equity shares in a company makes you a part-owner, similarly, fractional ownership in real estate offers you to invest in shares of real estate properties making you the owner of the property limited to the money invested. Thus, gone are the days when owning a real estate property was a gigantic task of putting together a huge sum of money to purchase a commercial property.

Fractional ownership has opened up a smarter way of investing in commercial real estate for people having limited capital. Through fractional ownership, a special purpose vehicle is created where investors pool in their money which is allocated small ticket-sized shares. This pool of money is then invested to purchase a huge ticket-sized commercial property worth crores. The investor earns a regular share in rentals of the investment property as well as capital appreciation at the time of sale. Along with that, certain fractional ownership properties also allow you access to property usage rights.

What is a Real Estate Investment Trust (REIT)?

Real Estate Investment Trusts are companies that own and manage a wide range of commercial properties or even offer financing options at the early stages of the project. Investing in such REITs is facilitated through Mutual Funds which invest in such Real Estate Companies or Direct Investing on Stock Exchange. Thus, profits made by the company are transferred to the investors through dividends, and also the market price appreciation reflecting the worth of the company can reap substantial returns.

Recently, the Indian Financial Markets witnessed the listing of three REITs namely, Embassy Office Parks, Mindspace Business Parks, and the Brookfield India Real Estate Trust on the stock exchange. With their entry, the REITs space has garnered a lot of attention from retail investors too. This is evident due to the number of benefits that REITs provide. Investing in REITs allows you to invest in real estate indirectly. Thus, the hassles that come with an actual property investment get eliminated. Moreover, the add-on costs associated with the maintenance of the property are also saved. Thus, REITs are more convenient for people wanting to get real estate exposure with limited capital.

Now that we have a clear perspective on what Fractional Ownership and REITs entail, it’s time to dive deeper into their differentiating aspects and build a leaner view of both the investing options.

Fractional Ownership Vs REITs: The difference?

Comparison Points

Fractional Ownership

REITs

Type of Property 

Fractional Ownership has no constraints on the type of property. Thus, investment can be done in both under construction as well as fully constructed properties.

According to SEBI guidelines, 80% of the investment should be in developed and income-generating properties. The rest can be invested in under-construction properties.

Choice of  property

Fractional Ownership offers complete control to investors in choosing the property

REITs offer no control as the management decides in choosing the property after due diligence.

Lock-in period

Fractional Ownership does not have any lock-in period. Investors can sell their stake in the property anytime.  

REITs generally come with a constraint of market value fluctuations of the company. Investors can profit only when they sell at higher prices.

Earnings

Distribution

The rental earnings from the property are distributed through SPVs at regular intervals.

The earnings by the REITs are distributed to the investors in the form of dividends with a payout ratio of 90%.

Ownership

Part-ownership in the property is acquired.

No ownership of the property is acquired.

Transferability

The ownership of property is freely transferable.

No transferability due to no ownership of property.

Diversification of Portfolio

Investors can diversify their portfolios as per their will.

Investors’ money is invested in a set portfolio created by the company.

Entry Cost

The entry cost can be comparatively higher than REITs

The entry cost is low as the company’s shares are listed on the stock exchange.

Valuation Requirements

Requires continuous valuations at frequent intervals.

Requires complete valuation for at least twice a year.

Understanding the above differentiating factors is crucial in deciding the best type of investment for yourself. Both the investment options have their pluses and minuses. Optimizing them is essential for investors to reap higher profits. For that, we have curated 4 parameters you need to consider before zeroing in on the investment option. Following is the list of 4 parameters to analyze.

Parameters to check before investing in Fractional Ownership or REITs

  • Capital Requirement

The first thing to know is your capacity to invest or the capital requirement for your investment. As we discussed above, fractional ownership requires a minimum amount of investment usually in the range of 10 to 25 Lakhs. However, the number changes based on the type of property and its worth.

For REITs, the initial capital to be invested depends on your ability. Even smaller investments are allowed for REITs.

  • Time Horizon

Knowing the time horizon for the investment is a must. Though both the investment options don’t have a lock-in period, it must be considered that to earn decent returns the time horizon should be longer. For REITs, exiting the investment in the short term may not provide you with complete benefits. Similarly, a commercial fractional ownership property requires some initial years to stabilize the returns.

  • The expectation of Returns

Generally, fractional ownership provides higher annual returns as compared to REITs. Moreover, REITs are subject to stock market fluctuations and thus offer a risk factor. Thus, from a volatility perspective, fractional ownership investments fare better due to the consistent distribution of rental cash flows.

  • Expertise to monitor investments

If you possess the expertise to monitor your real estate investments, then fractional ownership is more suitable to you as it requires continuous valuations and due diligence from the investor. However, if you have very limited knowledge about managing real estate investments, then REITs are the right option for you as the REIT itself manages the whole portfolio and optimizes the returns for the investors.

The real estate sector is vast and understanding the same can be sometimes daunting. With this article, we hope you are better prepared for making the right decision between Fractional Ownership and REITs to make the best out of your real estate investment. Any investor needs to know the nitty-gritty of every investment avenue before taking the further step. Both Fractional Ownership and REITs offer a unique way of investing in real estate as compared to the traditional methods. Leveraging them will surely boost your investment graph and become a great value addition to your portfolio. And the most important thing, don’t miss is to check on the parameters before finalizing your investment. Enjoy the world of real estate and taste the returns it serves!

For investing in fractional ownership properties, Assetmonk is the best place for you. Assetmonk offers smart real estate investment options ranging from Growth, Growth Plus, and Yield models to grow your investment with an expected IRR of 21 percent per annum. To get started in the right direction of real estate investing, visit our website today!

Fractional Ownership & REITs FAQ'S:

Fractional Ownership in its literal terms means part ownership in any asset. On the other hand, investment in REITs is an investment in Real Estate Investment Trusts companies that own and manage a wide range of commercial properties or even offer financing options at the early stages of the project.

Fractional Ownership in its literal terms means part ownership in any asset. Just like owning a percentage of equity shares in a company makes you a part-owner, similarly, fractional ownership in real estate offers you to invest in shares of real estate properties making you the owner of the property limited to the money invested. The investor earns a regular share in rentals of the investment property as well as capital appreciation at the time of sale. Along with that, certain fractional ownership properties also allow you access to property usage rights.

According to the numbers of recent REITs, they have provided higher returns than private real estate investments. However, optimization of returns depends on multiple factors in private real estate investments like location, quality of tenants, economic conditions, and so on. Moreover, REITs entail the risk of market price fluctuation as they are listed on the stock exchange.

Fractional Ownership in its literal terms means part ownership in any asset. Through fractional ownership, a special purpose vehicle is created where investors pool in their money which is allocated small ticket-sized shares. This pool of money is then invested to purchase a huge ticket-sized commercial property worth crores.

No, fractional ownership properties are not any type of security as they cannot be traded in the secondary market.

Related Articles

istockphoto 1439112216 612x612 1

EPF Form 31 – Partial Withdrawal

EPF Form 31 is used by employees to register claims for a fractional withdrawal of money from the EPF. Employees’ Provident Fund is a savings scheme backed by the govt. that can help employed persons establish a substantial corpus to satisfy their financial obligations after retiring. Employees are expected to deposit a percentage of their basic salary (12 percent) per month to this type of PF. The employer then makes a matching contribution to this investment. The corpus for workers is generated by pooling these deposits with relevant government interest. Employees might also opt to pull from their EPF savings throughout their job tenure to pay any unexpected bills that may occur. Also, read EPF Form 11. When can you withdraw your EPF funds?  An individual can withdraw his EPF money in part or in full via EPF withdrawal Form 31 only under particular conditions. Employees are eligible for withdrawal of their whole EPF savings amount in the events listed…

Read more
istockphoto 1200759231 612x612 1

EPF Passbook Download

Employees can download EPF Passbook online. Employee provident Fund Organisation offers an EPF passbook service online. It functions similarly to a passbook of a bank in that it records an individual’s EPF account spending. It allows one to easily see, import, and print their account statement. This online EPFO member passbook may also be accessed via the program. But, prior to installing the EPFO passbook, the UAN passbook must be unlocked. So, the EPF passbook is a database that contains a record of all contributions made to EPS and EPF accounts by the worker and the employer. The passbook details all contributions made each month. Interests earned in the account of the beneficiary are still kept in the passbook. Read EPF – Employees’ Provident Fund, EPFO Benefits & Process. Information in the EPF Passbook The company’s or employer’s name The ID of the establishment  The type and name of the EPFO office Contributions from both the employer and the employee…

Read more
istockphoto 1353920585 612x612 1

PF Form 19

The Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act of 1952 requires a worker to pay a set compensation payment to the PF account, and an employer must contribute an equivalent amount. Withdrawals under this program need to complete several forms, one of which is PF Form 19. Read EPF Withdrawal: How to Fill PF Form & Get Claim Online. PF Form 19 Is? Whenever a subscriber wishes to finalize his PF account, PF Form 19 must be completed. This only applies to workers without a UAN or Universal Account Number. So, it is possible to fill even if one does not possess a Universal Account Number, and an employee will only have to provide his PF account number. PF Form 19  will be utilized to request a settlement that is final of the PF account or to withdraw pension payments. A variety of PF Forms are accessible, each having a particular function. To achieve the intended result, these forms must…

Read more
National Pension Scheme tier 1 account

National Pension Scheme Tier 1

The National Pension Scheme Tier-1 Account represents the most fundamental type of pension fund account provided by GOI.  The govt plan aims to meet the retirement demands of private and public sector workers. To provide a framework for the use of NPS, the govt has divided it into two separate tiers: Tier 1 & Tier 2. The National Pension Program (NPS) is a national pension scheme that attempts to meet employees’ retirement needs in private and public industries. Read NPS Vs PPF: Comparison, Return Rates & Which is Better. Tier 1 NPS Account Aspects The following are a few major features of the Tier 1 NPS Account that distinguish it from the NPS Tier 2 account. Tier 1 NPS Account constitutes the most fundamental type of pension account. Early withdrawals from the Tier 1 NPS Account are permitted, but only like reimbursable advances and only after the investor has served for fifteen years. These withdrawals are permitted only in an…

Read more
password reset

UAN Password reset

As all Employee Provident Fund activities are being done online, the UAN, or Universal Account Number, is now the only ticket to operating the online EPF platform. With the advent of UAN, activities such as PF withdrawal, monitoring PF balance, applying for loans against PF, and so on have become much easier and more accessible to individuals. Furthermore, the UAN stays constant and transferable across an employee’s career. Employees must have membership IDs, that are eventually connected to the employee’s UAN, even if they change employers. Given the gravity of the situation, you must not lose your UAN and passwords. But, if you continue to lose or forget your UAN Password, follow the instructions below to generate it. Read EPF – Employees’ Provident Fund, EPFO Benefits & Process. But what if you forget your UAN Password? To restore or modify your UAN password, abide by the rules below: Open the EPF online portal. On the webpage, on the right-hand side,…

Read more
Customer care support

NPS Customer Care

The National Securities Depository Limited Central Record Keeping Agency or NSDL CRA (NPS Customer Care) may be reached @ (022) 2499 3499. One can also lodge any complaint electronically with the NSDL CRA’s Central Grievance Management System (CGMS) or with Karvy CRA. In the NPS, NSDL and Karvy are Central Recordkeeping Agencies (CRAs). NSDL’s location is 1st Floor, Times Tower, kamala Mills Compound, Senapati Bapat Marg, Lower Parel, Mumbai – 400 013 and Fax Number: (022) 2495 2594/ 2499 4974. The details for NPS grievance escalation are shown below. If one is dissatisfied with the settlement offered by NSDL/Karvy, one may submit a complaint directly to the watchdog, the Pension Funds Development and Regulatory Authority (PFRDA). Do not miss NPS Vs PPF: Comparison, Return Rates & Which is Better. NPS Grievances Escalation Level Level I Escalation  Official’s Name Mr. Chandrashekhar Warange Details For Contact  Tel Number: 022 24993499 Email: gro@nsdl.co.in Position Grievance Redressal Officer (GRO) Level II Escalation Official’s Name…

Read more